When a serious workplace injury or fatality occurs, employers are often focused on what’s immediately in front of them: ensuring injured employees receive medical attention, securing the scene, addressing any immediate hazards and preparing for a potential inspection. But placing all of your attention on dealing with the Occupational Safety and Health Administration investigation that follows an incident misses a much larger issue. Workplace injuries and fatalities can create substantial legal, financial, operational and reputational risks that extend well beyond an OSHA inspection. This article will cover five unforeseen costs that typically come along with a workplace accident and how you can prepare.
1. Your Legal Exposure Does Not End With OSHA
A serious injury or death on the worksite can trigger multiple legal proceedings, often simultaneously. When an incident involves a subcontractor, determining responsibility for the worker’s care may lead to disputes such as third-party personal injury litigation or contractual indemnification claims.
Employers should keep in mind that, with contractors or third-party staff, they can face allegations involving negligent supervision, inadequate safety procedures or unsafe premises. Litigation brings discovery, experts, legal expenses, and potentially significant settlements or judgments.
Employees are also protected when it comes to raising safety concerns under various federal and state whistleblower and anti-retaliation laws. In unionized workplaces, the same incident may generate grievances, arbitration proceedings or unfair labor practice charges.
OSHA may not be the only agency with an interest in the event. Depending on the facts, hazardous-material releases may involve environmental reporting or enforcement. Transportation-related incidents may draw scrutiny from transportation regulators. Other state-specific workplace protection or workers’ compensation issues may also arise.
Overlapping investigations create document requests, interviews and reporting requirements. Employers should promptly work with counsel to determine which documents should be preserved, especially when litigation is reasonably anticipated. Mishandling evidence can create exposure independent of the underlying incident.
2. Financial Consequences Can Far Exceed Penalties
The true price of a workplace accident doesn’t end at the OSHA penalty.
For many employers, the largest financial consequences are the costs that continue accumulating long after the inspection ends. Workers’ compensation claims can affect an employer’s experience modification rate (EMR), potentially increasing premiums and affecting eligibility for future work. In construction and other industries where customers evaluate safety performance during bidding, an elevated EMR may become a competitive disadvantage. An employer may resolve its OSHA citation yet continue to lose opportunities because of its safety metrics.
Depending on claims history and policy terms, general liability and umbrella carriers may increase premiums, deductibles, or self-insured retentions. Larger incidents may require temporary staffing or overtime if workers are out recovering. Equipment may need to be repaired or replaced. And your corporate management team will have to spend more work hours working to mitigate the accident, all factors that add additional expenses that insurance may not fully cover.
3. Employee Morale and Workplace Culture Matter
After a serious injury or fatality, employees may question whether their employer is taking appropriate steps to protect them. If concerns are not effectively addressed, the company may face declining morale, absenteeism, turnover and difficulty attracting qualified workers.
Employees pay attention not only to management’s statements but also to its actions. In unionized workplaces, unresolved safety concerns can contribute to grievances or labor disputes. And in non-union workplaces, it could also encourage employees to launch a union organizing campaign based on safety issues.
Ensure your communications to employees following the incident respond to legitimate concerns you’ve received from staff. Implementing corrective measures specific to your employee’s complaints can help preserve confidence. A disorganized or dismissive response can compound the harm.
For example, if employees request additional training despite not being due for recertification, consider voluntary refresher programs. Incident response training and drills in the aftermath of an incident can help employees feel safer and more prepared in case another accident happens in the future.
4. Reputational Damage Can Outlast the Inspection
A company can successfully defend against an OSHA citation and still lose in the court of public opinion.
A serious workplace incident can easily become the subject of a news story or draw attention from investors. Customers, employees or members of the public may ask questions or scrutinize the company’s decisions. Negative publicity following an accident can damage relationships and invite oversight from insurers, lenders and stakeholders.
Employers should also keep in mind that commercial contracts may contain safety-performance, reporting or corrective-action provisions. Depending on their terms, a serious incident could jeopardize existing contracts or future bids.
Even if operations restart and OSHA is no longer investigating, it doesn’t necessarily mean the business has avoided the consequences of the incident.
5. Workplace Safety Is an Enterprise Risk
A strong workplace safety program can serve as an effective enterprise risk management strategy against exacerbating concerns.
One injury may lead to an OSHA investigation and workers’ compensation claim. In turn, those matters may increase insurance costs and unfavorable safety metrics may limit bidding eligibility. As a result, lost opportunities may reduce revenue and operational disruptions from the accidents may compound the financial crunch.
Your organization should prepare incident-response plans that touch all the risk areas we’ve discussed in this Insight before an accident happens. That includes designating clear responsibilities for what staff handle workers compensation and employee leave needs, as well as ensuring management coordinates with legal, safety and operations, following an accident. Prepare for the legal, employee benefit and broader business consequences that may come from an accident as part of your response plan, not just citation avoidance.
Conclusion
We are always monitoring developments in workplace safety policy, so make sure you are subscribed to Fisher Phillips’ Insight system to get the most up-to-date information directly to your inbox. If you have further questions, contact your Fisher Phillips attorney or any attorney in our Workplace Safety Practice Group.
This article has been edited for length. To view the original article, visit fisherphillips.com.



